Post-installation in concrete – cracked or non-cracked?
It’s quite common that steel structures need to be anchored to concrete structures afterwards - everything from hanging installations to fastening beam supports. The types of post-installed fasteners are almost endless: expansion anchors, concrete screws, chemical anchors, and so on. In this jungle, it’s easy to overlook one important aspect - whether the concrete should be considered cracked or non-cracked.
Concrete is a brittle material with relatively low tensile strength. This is compensated for by reinforcement inside the concrete, which absorbs tensile forces and holds cracks together when they form. Cracks in the concrete not only affect how the structure itself behaves, but also how the fasteners perform. Cracks influence the way stresses are distributed locally around the anchor point where loads are transferred, which reduces the concrete’s load-bearing capacity. In some cases, the capacity of the same anchor can be half in cracked concrete compared to non-cracked. When the concrete is cracked, there’s a high chance that a crack runs along the drill hole for the fastener. This slightly widens the hole and makes it flex under load, increasing the risk of slippage - and if the fastener isn’t tested and approved for cracked concrete, it may loosen completely without warning.
As mentioned, testing and approvals determine the correct area of use. It’s not something you can see with the naked eye. Two products may look almost identical but still be approved for completely different purposes (see Figure 1). Sometimes you’ll see the terms “Option 1” (cracked concrete) and “Option 7” (non-cracked concrete). These names come from common test programs in the ETA assessment documents, which define what performance and applications can be declared. If the anchor hasn’t been tested in cracked concrete, its performance there is unknown and it shouldn’t be used in those areas. If it has been tested in cracked concrete, it’s also tested in non-cracked concrete. Tests in cracked concrete are therefore more extensive and complex but cover both conditions.
So, when should you assume that the concrete is cracked? Cracks form in areas where the tensile stress exceeds the tensile strength of the concrete. Typical locations are above supports in continuous beams and slabs, or along the bottom side at mid-span between supports (see Figure 2). When cracks occur due to restrained movement - for example, from drying shrinkage or temperature changes - it’s harder to predict exactly where the cracks will appear.
Figure 1. Expansion anchor for non-cracked concrete on top and for cracked concrete below.
Figure 2. Commonly cracked areas.
For the fastening, it doesn’t matter whether the crack is present at the time of installation or appears later on - in fact, it can be even worse if it develops afterward. For this reason, only areas that are under compression can generally be considered non-cracked. If they are not, it’s best to assume the area is cracked, even if no cracks are visible at the time of installation.
Given how difficult it is to determine whether the concrete should be classified as cracked or non-cracked, it’s recommended to assume it is cracked and use fasteners approved for that condition (for example, Option 1) whenever the circumstances are not fully known or a structural engineer has not performed a detailed analysis. Since anchors approved for cracked concrete also work in non-cracked concrete, this approach ensures safety. That way, you can be confident that the fastening will deliver the intended performance both now and in the future - for a relatively small additional cost.
FAuthor: Niclas Görander, Technical Consultant at Pretec Sweden
Read the full article at SBI: https://www.stalbyggnad.se/fastelementtipset/eftermontage-i-betong-sprucket-eller-osprucket/
Interested in learning more about post-installation in concrete?
Can’t find the information you’re looking for? Our technical consultant, Niclas Görander, will be happy to answer your questions. Don’t hesitate to get in touch if you’d like to know more!